Ethics on the Edge: Nurses Exploiting Patients for Social Media Content

During the Crimean War, Florence Nightingale did not exploit the wounded for personal gain or publicity. Although social media did not exist at the time, she had the option to use the press but chose not to. Instead, Nightingale used the lamp to symbolize her commitment to the nursing profession, rather than resorting to modern tools like selfies or cameras. Her focus was not on self-interest or public attention but on providing compassionate care to the sick and injured. Florence Nightingale became the Mother of Nursing because of her selfless acts.

She was passionate about her Environmental Theory not about her public image.

Fast forward to today, many, though not all, nursing students are using their patients as digital content on social media. Recently, I was shocked to learn that a nursing student recorded the dying moments of a patient—specifically, “the precise time when the electrocardiogram reading flatlined”—and then uploaded this video footage to a public social media account. The post went viral and garnered widespread attention from people in the healthcare profession.

Florence Nightingale must be turning in her grave.

The nursing profession is not a normal occupation. It is imbued with public interest, and it has cultural, professional, and moral underpinnings. In fact, the Board of Nursing passed Board Resolution No. 220, Series of 2004 or the Promulgation of the Code of Ethics for Registered Nurses to enforce a body of ethical standards or norms for Filipino Nurses.

Section 1 of the Code of Ethics provides that — The Filipino registered nurse, believing in the worth and dignity of each human being recognizes the primary responsibility to preserve health at all costs. It is expanded by Section 8 of the same Code of Ethics, in this wise: Nurses must Respect Patients’ Bill of Rights in the delivery of nursing care. One of the patient’s bill of rights is the right to privacy and respect.

Registered nurses are aware that their actions have professional, ethical, moral, and legal dimensions. They strive to perform their work in the best interest of all concerned and to carry out their duties under existing laws, rules, regulations, and generally accepted principles of moral conduct and proper decorum.

During my first week of nursing study at West Visayas State University, it was impressed upon us that the focus of nursing care is always the patient. Theoretical foundations of nursing practice, particularly those advocated by Dr. Jean Watson, emphasize that nursing should consider the whole person.

A dying person remains a person, and a nursing student should use his or her time to either prevent death or assist the patient in achieving a comfortable and peaceful end. I cannot understand how posting on social media could be a priority during such a critical moment.

This issue presents a critical challenge for the Board of Nursing to update its Code of Ethics to address the conduct of nurses in the online realm. Professional organizations must adapt to contemporary realities that jeopardize the sacred trust placed in the nursing profession. Filipino nurses are renowned for their compassion and competence, which is why the Philippines remains a leading exporter of nursing talent globally. We cannot allow narcissistic tendencies to tarnish this esteemed profession.

It is imperative that we collectively work to uphold and elevate the standards of nursing, ensuring that our actions reflect the true spirit of care and professionalism.

Finally, our nursing schools should prioritize not only developing the skills of nursing students but also shaping their attitudes.

About the Author:

Michael “Mikee” De la Peña is both a lawyer and a nurse, currently serving as a policy officer at a health think tank in the Philippines.

In his legal practice, he manages cases related to civil and criminal litigation, non-profit law, health policy, and intellectual property rights. He is also pursuing a Master of Laws degree at Ateneo de Manila University, focusing on Intellectual Property Law and Health Governance.

We are nurses, we are not less.

Just in case the news skipped your notice Mr. President, thousands of our skilled Filipino nurses are now leaving the country not because they want to touch the snow in London, not because they want to visit Santorini in Greece, not because they want to date a handsome and hunky Caucasian or a rich Arab woman, but because our system forced them to do so.  Our callous disregard to their rights made them to believe that they are second-class healthcare workers. Verily, our nurses suffer the lowest possible indecency a country can inflict to its professional workers. And they have valid license from the Professional Regulation Commission. They are required to have an accumulated CPD units, but when our nurses require the same good treatment from this government, what do they get? — Nothing!

Again, I’m sorry to speak about this, but I can’t sleep seeing my fellow nurses suffer. I am not working in a hospital but my heart is still beating for my profession. My heart is still beating for the Nightingale in white, in blue and in scrubs. Allow me to speak for them.

I don’t blame you Mr. President that you are currently focusing on “War on Drugs”, but as a form of request, can we give equal attention to those who fight alongside with you inside the hospitals, the fences of communities, penal institutions and healthcare centers?

How can we possibly heal the country if our healers are wounded themselves?

How can we miraculously rehabilitate this archipelago if our nurses are now starting to fly abroad?

Currently, I’m envious about the attention you give to “Jeepney Modernization”. In my mind, “lucky are the jeepneys, for they will be modernized soon”, but pain are for our poor nurses who will still be living and working in areas where modernization is not part of the plan.

Make no mistake Mr. President, our nurses are still living with healthcare technology which placed themselves in the brick of danger.  These are competent and intelligent Filipinos who passed the board exams.  In fact, we cannot even provide them with  adequate soap and alcohol for their hand sanitation, N92 masks for personal protection, and heavens sake, we don’t pay them with dignity.

Before it’s too late Mr. President, I would like to invite your attention to this maladies enveloping our Filipino nurses. They deserve to experience the “change” that you promised during the election season. Or should I treat this as another form of fake news?

#Mutya

 

PNA too irrelevant, mediocre- nurses say

Philippine Nurses Association is currently under fire from nurses who are expecting for more meaningful content postings in the organization’s social media accounts.

A concerned group named “Nurses for change” asked the highest governing body of professional nurses to post relevant issues such as nurses’ rights instead of advertising for seminars or training.

pna

In addition, netizens joined the sentiment of the group, some blatantly described PNA as a mediocre organization.

With what is happening concerning the nursing profession in the Philippines, it is clear as day that nurses are starting to get dissatisfied from the governing body.

Enshrined in the purpose of the PNA is “To promote professional growth towards the attainment of highest standards of nursing.”

However, this does not sit well with the nurses who are expecting more from the organization. Some of the nurses even said that PNA is too distant and too insignificant to their professional growth given the fact that nurses (both the old and the new) pay for their registration fee, once every year.

-Mutya

photocredit: http://globalnation.inquirer.net/

Force Volunteerism among nurses needs to stop.

Once upon a time, I was a volunteer nurse.

No benefits, no stipend, no whatever. No, seriously. As far I know, this is the only profession that ‘requires’ you to work without pay for so long just for the ”experience”.

So I got sick and tired.

Fast forward to now, there are still licensed nurses out there rendering their services for free. It needs to stop. The truth is, most of the time, in the Philippine setting, you can’t climb too far up the ladder without strings to pull. And even if you get promoted to N1 or N2 level, the salary still ain’t up to par. No one can blame the nurses who leave their loved ones to take their chances abroad, or find non-health services related jobs. You know, jobs with REAL pay to make ends meet.


I hope this government will live up to its promise for change to come because I really want the system to change from being pro-capitalist to pro-everyone. Which is unrealistic. Alright then, more pro-working class than ever, especially to practicing nurses out there.

From the Facebook post of Ms. Karen Joy Torralba, RN

I’m a nurse but I opted not to continue working in the hospital now.

After I filed an online petition to President Duterte, I received a letter from Marites, who asked me if her story can be featured in my blog. I  was hesitant. How can I give justice to a non-fiction story, more especially if it is about her– being a nurse and a mother.

But, as an advocate for nurses. I devoted myself to continuously talk about the inequalities of the nursing profession in my own country. I told her, yes. I sent her, some guide questions which she can answer so that I can make a story out of it.


 

I’m a nurse but I opted not to continue working in the hospital now. Despite my passion to serve and care for the welfare of my patients, I chose to go out, put off the lamp of Florence Nightingale and venture to another path, where I can get enough, for my only baby girl.

Hindi ko mapapakain ang mga anak ko sa sahod bilang nurse.

(I can’t afford to feed my family with my salary as a nurse.)

With the meager 3,000 per two weeks (15 days) (sometimes even smaller depending  on the duty hours (kasi nga Reliever pa kami bago maging Regular Staff).

I served the public hospital for 3 years, again 3 long years without any reservations. I gave my life and time (pati overtime) na unpaid with the hope that one day, I will be promoted in a regular post.

However, one day, I felt like, they are not serious in promoting me. A new nursing graduate was assigned the vacant posts, very easily. Then I learned that, she was the daughter of the assistant chief nurse of the hospital. It crushed my heart. It was injustice.

I pay the BIR, SSS, PAG-IBIG, and PhilHealth and other applicable state taxes, hoping that the government will be nicer to us me—as a nurse. But, I was very stupid to believe that the government is passionate and caring.

While working in the hospital, I have no choice but to leave my own child under the care of a babysitter. I have no choice. Then, one day, I realized that;

Naku! mas malaki pa sweldo ni yaya kesa sa akin! parang nag-nurse ako para may pasweldo at pang SSS and Philhealth ang yaya.

Nurses na yata ang susunod na martyr sa Pilipinas! Seeing that I could not even feed my self three times a day, and my baby with the right amount of milk, I decided to say,

“Enough is enough! It must stop!”

In the Philippines, nurses are disregarded. Nurses are not the priority despite the hardships and sacrifices that we give. We care but no one is caring for us.  Before I resigned, I went to the office of our Chief Nurse, I looked at her in the eye, and I delivered the arrow that pierced her heart.

Where is the government?

Where is your conscience?

For nurses to triumph, one should not be afraid to speak. Nurses should throw the appropriate arrows, right to the heart, especially if you are facing the beasts that kill the essence of the nursing profession, even though he/she is also a nurse.

(Story of Maritess, a nurse and a loving mother)

Share your own story to ikuwentokaymutya@gmail.com.